Big Pharma Fights Drug Rulings In India
Landmark drug patent protection cases involving Bayer, Roche, and Novartis are advancing in India this month. Together, they will help determine how friendly the country is to Western pharmaceutical makers.
Landmark drug patent protection cases involving Bayer, Roche, and Novartis are advancing in India this month. Together, they will help determine how friendly the country is to Western pharmaceutical makers.
On Sept. 3, Bayer filed an appeal with the Intellectual Property Appellate Board in Chennai over a compulsory license order entitling the Indian firm Natco Pharma to produce a generic version of the Bayer kidney and liver cancer drug Nexavar. Issued in the spring, the license let Natco onto the market by paying Bayer a modest 6% royalty on sales of the generic drug. The order marks the first time that a foreign branded drug has been subject to compulsory licensing in India.
On Sept. 7, Roche lost a case in the High Court of Delhi, where it had argued that the Indian drug producer Cipla was infringing on its patents by selling a generic version of the lung cancer drug Tarceva. In a 275-page ruling, the court sided with Cipla’s contention that Tarceva is based on a different polymorph of the active ingredient erlotinib than the one Roche patented in India. Roche had attempted to patent the different polymorph, but India rejected it as too similar to the patented one.
“We are strongly considering an appeal,” Roche says. “Many of the cheap generic drugs today used in India were once patent-protected and are only available to society because companies such as Roche were willing to take a risk by investing in new innovative drugs.”
Meanwhile, on Sept. 11, Novartis began contesting in India’s Supreme Court key features of the pharmaceutical patent regime that the country instituted in 2005. The Novartis challenge follows India’s repeated refusal to grant patent protection to the cancer drug Gleevec on the grounds that it is nothing more than a new crystal form of an older compound. Gleevec enjoys patent protection in most major markets around the world.
“Novartis challenged the decision not to grant a patent to our life-saving medicine Gleevec because we strongly believe safeguarding incentives for innovation through the granting of patents leads to better medicines for patients,” the company says.
Although each case involves its own complex scientific and legal circumstances, drugmakers and patient activists are watching the disputes for the tone they collectively will set about intellectual property protection in India. Some observers see India as a model for the developing world.
Legal and medical scholars Peter Roderick and Allyson M. Pollock, at Queen Mary, University of London, argue that India’s system of intellectual property protection “should help rather than hinder” access to drugs in India. “The Bayer and Novartis cases are seeking to undermine public health considerations aimed at improving access and therapeutic advantage,” they write
By Jean-Fran?ois Tremblay
Related News
-
News Women in Pharma: Hiring Across the Gender Divide
In our monthly series, we interview women from across the pharmaceutical industry and supply chain to discuss the importance of gender diversity in healthcare, the workplace, and beyond. -
Sponsored Content Ashwagandha and Herbal Medicines: Pharma’s Next Big Opportunity
Herbal medicines and nutraceuticals have seen a surge in interest since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Driven by patient interest in prioritising personalised and integrative medicines, the herbal ingredients industry is now faced with concerns pe... -
News Identifying Alzheimer’s Disease biomarker proteins with whole blood tests
A University of Manchester spin-out pharmaceutical company, PharmaKure, has reported successful study results for the quantification of Alzheimer’s Disease biomarker proteins with a whole blood test. -
News Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to boost mRNA vaccine initiatives in Africa with USD $40m
To address vaccine inequality and accessibility issues, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation aims to deliver USD $40m to various biotech companies and vaccine manufacturers in support of mRNA vaccine development. -
News Updated – Changing abortion pill access according to the US FDA and Supreme Court
After the approval of the medical abortion pill, mifepristone, by the US FDA, states across the USA approach the distribution of the pill differently, some ruling against allowing access to the drug. -
News Revolutionising cancer treatment with mRNA-based therapeutics
Global market for mRNA-based oncology therapeutics expected to reach USD $2 billion by 2029, with promising results for the combination of mRNA candidates with immune checkpoint inhibitors to treat solid tumours. -
News Breaking Barriers: Innovations in Oral Solid Dose Form Bioavailability
The effectiveness of a medication often hinges on its bioavailability – the rate and extent at which the active ingredient is absorbed into the bloodstream. When it comes to oral solid dose forms, such as tablets and capsules, the challenge lies ... -
News Choosing the Right CDMO Partner: A Comprehensive Guide
Finding the right partner for the development and manufacturing of your pharmaceutical or biopharmaceutical products is paramount. This is where Contract Development and Manufacturing Organizations (CDMOs) step in, offering their expertise and infrastr...
Position your company at the heart of the global Pharma industry with a CPHI Online membership
-
Your products and solutions visible to thousands of visitors within the largest Pharma marketplace
-
Generate high-quality, engaged leads for your business, all year round
-
Promote your business as the industry’s thought-leader by hosting your reports, brochures and videos within your profile
-
Your company’s profile boosted at all participating CPHI events
-
An easy-to-use platform with a detailed dashboard showing your leads and performance